User avatar
tante @tante@tldr.nettime.org
1mo
If you are a member of Codeberg e.V. please take the time to participate in the poll that was just sent out about banning vibe-coded projects on Codeberg.

Please agree to the proposal. Slop can live on GitHub.
:celeste_hearts_catgender@mk.absturztau.be:1
8
3
2
1
User avatar
Yet another Josh donor @crankylinuxuser@infosec.exchange
1mo
@tante

And how does one propose to tell if it's LLM-assisted code?

A code scanner? Like this Mary Shelly Frankenstein that's also 100% AI?

Good luck.
The first paragraph of Mary Shelly's Frankenstein, chapter 5 The "AI detector" is calling it 100% AI GPT.
1
0
0
0
User avatar
normy foxyoreos @foxyoreos@mastodon.social
1mo
AI, Coderberg Meta @crankylinuxuser @tante this gets brought up a lot, but my perspective is:

A) a lot of AI projects are proud of it and will disclose it somewhere.

B) the collaborative nature of Open Source makes it difficult for larger projects to hide process details indefinitely.

C) if the outcome of this is that projects using AI hide their usage and don't evangelize it, that is a significant win that we should take.

AI "detection" is unnecessary for a rule like this.
1
1
1
0
User avatar
normy foxyoreos @foxyoreos@mastodon.social
1mo
AI, Coderberg Meta @crankylinuxuser @tante programmers are some of the biggest AI evangelists right now, and if a bunch of them start hiding their usage, that is a serious blow to companies like Microsoft and Anthropic who are counting on them to help drive a narrative about demand.

We take those wins; those are real wins. I want people using AI to hide their usage rather than to be public about it, I want it to be something that's culturally shameful to admit.
2
1
1
0
User avatar
Yet another Josh donor @crankylinuxuser@infosec.exchange
1mo
AI, Coderberg Meta @foxyoreos @tante

Are you shameful of spellcheck?

How about Markov chains and spam detection?

Are IDEs "AI"? Like function completion, or auto completing templating?

Or if its about training and recitation, are you against PID control loops? 3 neurons.

Or STT/TTS assistive technologies offensive to those disabled people?

Or is this how much data is in the statistical array? Is 1B OK, but 35B bad?

Cause this nebulous term " AI" doesn't actually mean anything. Has no scientific definition, and has changed hundreds of times even in my professional life.

Just how far up the statistical computing ladder do we go before its "evil"?

And LLMs are just tools. I am a tool user. Just so happens that I run my own .
3
0
0
0
User avatar
normy foxyoreos @foxyoreos@mastodon.social
1mo
AI, Coderberg Meta @crankylinuxuser @tante See, it's exactly like I said: detection isn't a problem because LLM users will tell you :3
2
0
0
0
User avatar
walnut 🌱 @walnut@thesoftestpaws.net
1mo
AI, Coderberg Meta @foxyoreos @tante
It takes a rhetorical genius to prove your point perfectly and not even realise it
0
6
17
0